Hyde-Away Restaurant & Tap Room
901 County Road 521, Middleville / Newton mailing
973-300-1888
Cozy restaurant and tavern serving New American comfort food with Italian and Spanish influences.
Stillwater Township
Food & Drink
Stillwater, Middleville and Swartswood dining — researched across the township rather than limited to one postal name.
No currently verified listings match this filter. NJTGO only assigns GF/DF badges when current information supports them.
Allergy & cross-contact caution: GF and DF badges indicate currently documented choices or accommodations, not an allergen-free kitchen. Shared equipment, prep areas, fryers and changing ingredients can create cross-contact. Diners with celiac disease or food allergies should confirm current preparation procedures directly before ordering.
Restaurants & Taverns
Blue Heron Tavern at North Shore House
912 Swartswood Rd, Newton mailing
973-383-5460
Reservation-based lakeside tavern with a changing seasonal menu and views of Swartswood Lake. Current materials support gluten-free and vegan accommodations.
GFDF
Stillwater Café
912 Main St, Stillwater
Chef-run restaurant in the historic general-store building, currently known for reservation-based multi-course Saturday dinners.
Pizza & Italian
Mengo's Pizzeria
911 Swartswood Rd, Newton mailing
973-300-1066
Local pizzeria offering pizza, Italian takeout, delivery and catering. A current menu lists a gluten-free pizza.
GF
Deli & Quick Service
Swartswood Deli
911 Swartswood Rd, Newton mailing
973-579-3354
Country-style deli and convenience market with breakfast sandwiches, subs, prepared food and grab-and-go items.
Cafe & Farm Stop
Campagna Café & Coffee Roasters
904 County Road 521, Middleville / Newton mailing
973-919-7422
Small-batch coffee roaster, café and farm stop with espresso drinks, baked goods, prepared foods and locally sourced provisions.
Bars
Boomer's Place
1 County Road 521, Newton mailing
973-383-9227
Small neighborhood bar in the Stillwater/Middleville area.
Beverage Retail
Main Street Liquors
906 Main St, Stillwater
973-300-9060
Local beverage retailer serving the Stillwater village area.
Dietary verification: Blue Heron Tavern currently states that its chef can accommodate gluten-free and vegan dietary needs; its published menu materials also identify gluten-free and vegan dishes. Mengo's current menu lists a gluten-free pizza. DF is assigned to Blue Heron because a vegan accommodation necessarily excludes dairy, but diners should still confirm ingredients and cross-contact.